How to Get Rid of You Are Currently Editing a Commit

Have you ever found yourself in a Git predicament where you are “currently editing a commit” and don’t know how to proceed? Fear not, as there are specific steps you can take to resolve this issue. By following the guidelines outlined below, you can effectively navigate through this situation and continue with your Git operations smoothly.

Resolving ‘Currently Editing a Commit’ Error in Git

If you find yourself in the situation where Git informs you that you are “currently editing a commit,” there are a few steps you can take to resolve it:

Abort the Rebase:
- If you’re in the middle of a rebase operation and want to completely cancel it, use:
```
git rebase --abort
```
This command will return your branch to the state it was in before the rebase started.
Keep Changes and Abort:
- If you’ve made changes during the rebase that you want to keep, follow these steps:
  - First, create a backup branch of your current branch:
```
git branch my-backup
```
  - Then, abort the rebase:
```
git rebase --abort
```
  - Finally, merge the changes from the backup branch back into your current branch:
```
git merge my-backup
```
This approach allows you to retain your changes while canceling the rebase.
Use git rebase --quit (Git 2.12 and later):
- If you want to quit the rebase without resetting the HEAD to the original branch, you can use:
```
git rebase --quit
```
This command cleans up the rebase without affecting other aspects of your repository.

How to Modify a Specific Commit in Git

To modify a specific commit in Git, follow these steps:

Identify the Commit:
- First, use the git log command to view the commit history and find the commit hash or commit message of the specific commit you want to edit.
- Note down the relevant information about the commit you wish to modify.
Rebase Interactively:
- Run the following command, replacing HEAD~3 with the appropriate reference (e.g., commit hash or relative position):
```
git rebase -i HEAD~3
```
- This will open a text editor displaying the last three commits, with the oldest at the top.
- Next to each commit, you’ll see the word “pick.”
- Replace “pick” with “reword” for the commit whose message you want to edit.
- Save and close the file.
Edit the Commit Message:
- After saving the file, Git will interpret and automatically execute the commands.
- You’ll find yourself in a situation where the specific commit is your last commit.
- Make your desired changes to the commit message.
- Commit the changes using:
```
git commit --all --amend --no-edit
```
- This amends the commit message without changing the content of the commit itself.
Continue the Rebase:
- Finally, return to the previous HEAD commit using:
```
git rebase --continue
```
- Be aware that this process changes the SHA-1 of the commit and all its children, effectively rewriting the history from that point forward.
- If you push changes using git push --force, it can break repositories, so use caution.

Amending Git Commit Messages

To amend Git commit messages and make changes, you have a few options:

Rewriting the Most Recent Commit Message:
- If you want to change the most recent commit message, use the following command:
```
git commit --amend
```
- This will open your text editor, allowing you to edit the commit message. Save the changes, and the commit will be updated. Keep in mind that this effectively creates a new commit that replaces the old one.
Amending Older or Multiple Commit Messages:
- If you’ve already pushed the commit to GitHub, you’ll need to force push a commit with an amended message. However, be cautious with force pushes, as they alter the repository’s history.
- To amend older or multiple commit messages, follow these steps:
  - Navigate to the repository containing the commit you want to amend.
  - Use interactive rebase to display a list of the last n commits in your default text editor:
```
git rebase -i HEAD~n
```
  - Edit the list to specify which commits you want to amend. Save the changes.
  - Force push the updated commit history:
```
git push --force-with-lease origin EXAMPLE-BRANCH
```
  - Replace EXAMPLE-BRANCH with the actual branch name.

Reverting a Commit in Git

Reverting a commit in Git can be done using different approaches. Let’s explore a couple of methods:

Using git revert:
- The git revert command creates a new commit that undoes the changes introduced by a specific commit. It’s a safe way to revert a commit without rewriting history.
- To revert a specific commit, you’ll need its commit hash (usually the first few characters are sufficient). For example, if the commit hash is a72ef02, run:
```
git revert a72ef02
```
- This will create a new commit that effectively undoes the changes made by the original commit.
Using git reset (with caution):
- The git reset command allows you to move the branch pointer to a previous commit. However, it’s more aggressive and can rewrite history.
- To revert the last commit (assuming it’s the most recent one), you can use:
```
git reset HEAD~1
```
  This command moves the branch pointer back one commit, effectively “uncommitting” the last change.
- Important: Be cautious when using git reset, especially if you’ve already pushed the commit to a remote repository. Rewriting history can cause issues for collaborators.

Remember that both methods have their implications, so choose the one that best fits your situation. If you’re working in a shared environment, prefer git revert to avoid disrupting others. If you’re sure about rewriting history, use git reset followed by a force push (if needed) .

Pushing Changes in Git Repository

To push changes from your local Git repository to a remote repository, follow these steps:

Create a New Branch (Optional):
- If you’re working on a new feature or bug fix, it’s a good practice to create a new branch. Use the following command to create and switch to a new branch:
```
git checkout -b 
```
- Replace with a descriptive name for your branch.
Make Changes and Commit:
- Edit your files, add any new changes, and commit them using:
```
git add .
git commit -m "Your commit message"
```
Push to Remote:
- To push your local branch to the remote repository, use the following command:
```
git push -u origin 
```
- The -u flag sets up tracking information for your branch, allowing you to easily push and pull changes in the future.
Handling Non-Fast-Forward Errors:
- If your local branch is behind the remote branch, you’ll encounter a “non-fast-forward” error. Fetch the upstream changes first:
```
git fetch origin
```
- Then, rebase your local branch or merge the changes before pushing again.
Pushing Tags (Optional):
- To push a single tag, use:
```
git push origin 
```
- To push all tags, type:
```
git push origin --tags
```
Deleting a Remote Branch or Tag:
- To delete a branch on the remote repository:
```
git push origin :
```
- Note the space before the colon. This command deletes the branch on the remote.
Working with Forks (GitHub):
- If you’ve forked a repository, add an “upstream” remote URL to fetch updates from the original repository:
```
git remote add upstream 
```
- Fetch updates from the upstream repository:
```
git fetch upstream
```
- Now you can push your local branch to GitHub and initiate a pull request.

In conclusion, encountering the message “you are currently editing a commit” in Git may seem daunting at first. However, with the right knowledge and tools at your disposal, you can easily overcome this obstacle. By using commands such as ‘git rebase –abort’ to cancel the rebase, ‘git rebase –quit’ to clean up the rebase, and creating backup branches to retain changes, you can effectively manage and eliminate the dilemma of being stuck in a commit edit.

With these tips in mind, you can confidently navigate Git processes and ensure a seamless workflow without any hindrances.

Aug 17, 2023
Roderick Webb
No Comments